Showing posts with label compensation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label compensation. Show all posts

Monday, January 7, 2013

Employee Engagement – For Change Managers


Employee Engagement continues to plummet.  It has hit an all time low at about 30%.  HR has been working hard at reversing this trend for almost a decade, but nothing seems to work.  Maybe it’s time that HR calls on Change Managers to design and implement a new paradigm for employee engagement?  

Let’s start at the beginning.  HR and managers have worked for years to destroy employee engagement.  This was not intentional or malicious; it was done in the name of eliminating “employee entitlement.”  Several decades ago the belief emerged that employers had provided such a strong economic safety net that employees were not hungry; they had lost their incentive to perform.  

Employees, it was believed, had become complacent because they could rely on: annual merit pay increases; employer paid benefits, particularly for health; and a defined benefit pension plan if they could just put in enough time to “meet the numbers.”  Comfort equaled sloth and that accumulated into a lack of business performance.

The simple answer to this initiating belief became the next belief.  According to the emerging paradigm: business needed to create a “performance culture” where those who performed to defined standards would be afforded commensurate rewards.  The employer was to give up vestiges of paternalism; it was time for employees to grow up and take responsibility for their careers.    

To implement these beliefs HR changed its role.  It took a lot of economic hygiene off the table and replaced it with: pay for performance topped up with metric driven bonuses; defined contribution pension plans where employees managed their investments for retirement; and paid-time-off plans along with cost sharing for health benefits.  The underlying philosophy, at the hygiene level, was clear: “we’re in this together, but you're on your own.”  This belief system was imbued into the depths of HR – as it transformed itself into a “strategic partner” with a seat at the executive table.

Unfortunately, what was perceived as “entitlement” had one major benefit.  It relieved employees of economic worry and let them focus on their work.  To the extent possible, “entitlement” let people bring themselves into their jobs.  It gave them the autonomy to find purpose in their work.  It let employees feel engaged.

Those days are gone.  Most businesses are not going to build the economic safety net back into their cost structures.  Employee disengagement is here to stay; we created it, now we have to manage it; and managing it means that HR will need to change its beliefs and build a new paradigm.

Here’s where Change Managers can help.

Reduce the Economic Worry:
Compensation is a big issue for HR to unlearn.  An industry has been built up around the performance pay experiment that hasn’t worked.  There are lessons in the past pointing to the value of solid base pay that is marked to the market and then topped up by sharing company profits. 

Performance appraisal is another sacred cow in HR’s performance belief system.  This monster was created by linking pay to performance.  Unfortunately we don’t have the social engineering skills to make it work.  Now the system is dreaded by all and serves no one.  Empirical evidence tells us that it’s time to unlink pay from performance – if we can get HR to go along.

We need to work with HR to create an abundance mindset that encourages employees to constantly look for and interview for new job opportunities.  One of two things will happen: employees will either learn how good they’ve got it, or the company will learn it’s under-valuing them.  Either way the employee moves to a new economic reality.

Finally, severance is a reality that many employees will face; they shouldn’t have to fear it.  We need to help HR enunciate and communicate severance policies that respects the employees’ contribution based on their job level, age, and time in the job.  Employees deserve that peace of mind.

Stratify Employee Engagement:
The 30% figure is an aggregate; we need to help HR focus where it matters.  

Veterans in the workforce are invested; whereas new entrants aren’t; however, recruits from the “social media generation” are going to be difficult to engage.  Most aren’t looking for a career; they’re looking for an experience.  Is low engagement a form of resistance to be conquered or is it a temporal condition that requires patience?  Change Managers know the difference and have the appropriate tools for either situation.  

Where Change Managers need to apply some new thinking and find new tools for HR is for that sliver of talent that understands the company’s DNA and wants to carry the gene forward.  We need to work with HR to learn what it takes to engage those who are interested in the company’s future.

Communicate Tough Love:
Employees offer their unique gifts when they have purpose at work; however, purpose comes from principles.  Get HR to write down the principles of the business?  How are employees expected to act?  How should employees treat each other and their customers?

HR needs to let employees know the rules of the game and know they will be held accountable.  Change Managers can help through their knowledge of two way communication and expertise in setting up accountability regimes.


Let Customers Drive Engagement:
Companies have eroded their commitment to employees, and employees know it.  HR needs to work with management to give employees a purpose that transcends the company.  Employees want to be valued and customers provide this.  

Linking employees to customers is a sweet spot for Change Managers.  We know how to create a short line of sight between employees and customers – and we also know how to show HR and managers how to get out of the way.

It's Just A Beginning
So, the above are thought starters on how Change Management can help HR build a new paradigm for employee engagement.  This is important work if we are to avoid a backlash.  For years HR have worked with their companies to become “kinder and gentler” in an attempt to increase employee engagement.  It hasn’t worked.  I dread that, out of exasperation, management will return to harsh models of command and control.  

We must avoid this.  We must help HR find a new paradigm for employee engagement as supported to by advocates such as Daniel Pink; however, our first task will be to help HR look beyond itself and its constraining orthodoxies.  





Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Employee Disengagement


Employee engagement is a thing of the past.  It’s time to move on.  

“Why would I commit myself to a company that will ultimately lay me off?”  A young manager asked me this question last month.  I’m still struggling for an answer.

Why do we continue to delude ourselves about Employee Engagement?  We all know the numbers.  We know the trend.  Employees in the western world are disengaging from their companies at an accelerating rate – and this trend is catching on in the rest of the world.  Sure maybe Costco, Zappos, and Southwest Airlines are different, but for how long?

You can choose your study to show disengagement, but here’s a quote from a recent report: “In general (employee engagement) is down by 9% and in cases of some top-performers is down as much as 25%.  Even more worrying, 12% of top-performing employees are considering leaving their organizations and 17% confirm they are ‘uncertain’ about staying.”  These results come in light of the fact that:

  • We all know there is a strong correlation between high employee engagement and strong financial performance, and
  • We have been working on accelerating employee engagement for more than a decade.

So what’s going on here?  Well based on my experience and observations I have come to two main conclusions:

  • We changed the rules of the game, and
  • We’d better find new answers

1.     We Changed the Rules of the Game
The history of employee disengagement is well known so I won’t take up a lot of space here.

Basically the past 25 years have seen a thoughtful tearing down of many of the factors that attach people to their work.  We called the process “breaking the employee entitlement mentality”; however, it can also be a euphemism for “building a performance culture that focused employees on generating profits for the business and value for the shareholders.”

I'm not saying this was a bad thing.  I'm only observing that a consequence has been employee disengagement.  When we removed what we saw as “employee entitlement” we didn’t inject the “performance culture” with new ways to emotionally bind employees to their company.

2.     We’d Better Find New Answers
The last 25 years has seen a plethora of top-down people management solutions to the disengagement issue.

  • We created Values statements that assert employees as our most valuable asset while our actions showed that we valued profits and low cost structures.
  • We talked about talent pools and bench strength while delayering organizations thereby stripping them of institutional knowledge and mentoring capability.
  • We implemented performance pay systems that set individuals against each other.
  • We spoke of business opportunities while severing employees.
  • We sent communication down a pipeline that got so cluttered that it got clogged.
  • We conduted Employee Commitment surveys that resulted in mechanical solutions that only activated the employee immune system.
These initiatives haven’t worked.  We must stop polishing old solutions while hoping for different results.

We created disengagement and our current practices are reinforcing it.  Engagement will never again be anything more than temporary for small sets of employees who drift in and out of self-actualization at work.  However, that doesn’t mean that employees shouldn’t enjoy their work and be productive doing it.

I believe that we need to accept a new reality.  We need to open a discussion with employees to create a new manifesto about life at work.  I don’t have the complete answer but I think some of the elements are:
1.     Honesty:
Let’s just tell it like it is.  We’re in a global economy.  Business needs to survive if it is to provide opportunities to employees.  People understand this and understand that sometimes tough decisions must be made to protect the greater good.
2.     Customers:
Employees don’t work for a company anymore; they work for their customers.  Although employees understand the need for profits and shareholder value that does not motivate them.  Customers do.  Draw the shortest line possible between every employee and the end customer.
3.     Compensation:
Delink appraisals and compensation.  Get rid  of performance pay.  Structure pay against the market and distribute success through a bonus pool.  If someone believes they are underpaid then ask them to “bring an offer.”  It’s a free market.  Openly encourage employees to test the market.
4.     Respect:
The only commitment most companies can make to their employees to day is to severe them with respect.  Severance should not be an event of shame and rejection.  Severance is today’s early retirement.  Let’s treat it that way.

We need to add to this dialogue.  We need to find a replacement for employee engagement.  We need a construct for “employment” that matches the world we work in.