Showing posts with label Confucius. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Confucius. Show all posts

Friday, October 26, 2012

Innovation in Korea: Rules of the Mind


The Power of Innovation
The Asian invasion!  How soon will we face our fate?  Will the west be buried by Innovations from the east?  Will we be left in the dust?  

I think the answer is that we’re ok in the near term if my experience in South Korea is any indicator.

The whole concept of Innovation fascinates me. 
·      How do humans dig into their natural creativity and come up with ideas that move the world in a positive direction? 
·      Once you have an idea, how do you turn it into something useful?

I’ve worked around the world and I sense that some places are better at idea generation and implementation than others.  Why is this?

Well I recently spent more than two years in Korea building Innovation capability within a large company.  This gave me a chance to do first hand observation and research.  I found three things:
1.     The vast majority of employees are not engaged in Innovation.  Hierarchy and deference leave them out.
2.     Innovation in product extensions and “adjacent possible” new products is disciplined, rigorous, and repeatable.  The reverse engineering mantra of “faster, better, cheaper” is deeply ingrained in the rhythm of the business.
3.     Korea is a long way away from seeing a Steve Jobs, Mark Zuckerberg, Eric Schmidt, or Jeff Bezoz.  White space, game changing, blue ocean Innovation is rare in Korea

While I was in Korea I took time to get to know my hosts.  I questioned them about their history, culture, and future.  I visited their museums, landmarks, and festivals.  I studied and listened.  Ultimately I consolidated my learnings into a five page article.  Here is the summary: 

Innovation in Korea is the captive of uniformity of thought and respect for institutions, build on centuries of homogeneity and the teachings of Confucius.  

The entrepreneurial spirit in Korea is swallowed by its large conglomerates.  Seoul is not a hot bed of private equity investors.  Investment capital is generally consumed in the bureaucracy of entitlement.  Capital in Korea belongs to deference.

I respect the achievements of my Korean friends.  It’s impossible to downplay the economic “Miracle on the Han” or the legendary products and services coming out of: Samsung, LG, and Hyundai/Kia.

But is “faster, better, cheaper” the sum total of the Innovation story in Korea.  Will Korean businesses be able to engage the entire workforce and will their Innovators bring new business models to the global stage?

You can look deeper into these questions by reading the whole article: Innovation in Korea: Rules of the Mind

Friday, September 7, 2012

Korea: Psychotic Gangnam Style


"Where did these cars come from?"
Gangnam Style.  49,000,000 hits on YouTube!  Have you seen it?  It’s psychotic.  It’s the new Korean pop (K-pop) music video by Psy (short for Psychotic) that parodies the lifestyle in Gangnam (the most chic district of Seoul, South Korea).

I worked in Korea for 26 months.  Our team worked to transform one of Korea’s largest public companies.  We used innovation as a lever to engage employees and open the organization to new possibilities.  The more I understood what was happening outside our office the more effective I became inside. 

Gangnam Style lays open the schizophrenic culture of Korea.

I don’t claim to be an expert in interpreting Gangnam Stlye.  There are many others who have done this.  What I do see is that Psy is bringing out the vast cultural under currents in Korea.  For example, the video opens with him playing on a beach, which turns out to be a children’s sand box.  This is interpreted as a caricature of life in Gangnam where material excess is nothing more than a hollow imitation of hollow lives.

Psy has a point.  I have worked in most regions of the globe and I can’t think of a country with as much internal turmoil as Korea; turmoil that could explode.  Let’s take a brief look at modern Korea.

In 1960 the average per capita income of Koreans was $100.  Today (although I see lots of different figures) that number is in the range of $30,000 – compare that to something like $40,000 in the US.  The exact figures aren’t important.  What is important is the rocketing economic growth that took place in Korea over just a few decades.  The most accelerated time of growth was 1960 to 1997 – this is known as the Miracle on the Han (the river that runs through Seoul and much of the country).  Since 2000 the Korean economy has had steady annual growth - in the 2% to 4% range.  Korea is now the 15th largest economy in the world.

Just think of what this exceptional economic growth means to this country of 48,000,000 people and the impact it is having on a country that is now experiencing aging at a pace that is unprecedented in human history.  The percentage of Koreans 65 (born in 1947 or earlier) and above has sharply risen from 3.3% in 1955 to 10.7% in 2009.  Korea's population shape has changed from a pyramid in the 1990’s to a diamond in 2010.  The top of the diamond is an aging class that knows starvation and poverty coming out of the Korean War; the young class knows prosperity and the materialism of the west; people torn between these two worlds populate the middle of the diamond.

Although the middle is torn, it is also the layer that keeps the country politically stable and economically prosperous.  Above them are their parents who rarely greet their peers with: “How are you?”  It’s more likely that they ask, “Did you eat today?”  The parents are steeped in the teachings of Confucius with its hierarchy of respect and deference flowing from king to teacher to father.

Below the middle are the youth.  This is a wholly brand conscious, hip layer that is rejecting the past.  They see that their parents and other elders have sacrificed but now the young want to benefit from the prosperity of the nation.   Big shifts are evident in the attitudes of women who are well educated, have good jobs, and resist giving up Zara and Gucci for marriage and children.  Oh yes, obesity is becoming an issue as abundance and western food chains hit the streets.

The people in the middle recognize the strictness of the past.  They want to tone down the education system where scholastic high school seniors study 18 hours a day 7 days a week.  They also recognize that deference to the ideas and traditions of their elders is not progressive.  This is an anachronistic society.  The middle has to tie together kimchi (vegetables marinated underground for a year) and street carts with bullet trains and 103% penetration of cell phones.

So, when I see Psy in his energetic gyrations I see someone who is channeling the undercurrents in his country.

Where’s it going?  I don’t know.  The top of the diamond is stifling; the bottom of the diamond is unstable; the middle is getting tired of the straddle.  Soon Korea will need another Miracle on the Han.

Oh well, don’t worry; be happy; watch Gagnam Style.

Monday, August 20, 2012

"Twelve O''clock High": The Change Management Paradox


The Non-Participator
“Cut out this guidance stuff and just tell me what to do!”  That’s a quote from my son when he was nearing the end of his university education.  Like most young people he was unclear and anxious about his future.  As a good parent I was guiding him.  It wasn’t working; he wanted an answer.  That’s the paradox of parenting – it’s not your life, but you still have a responsibility.  Leading organizational change has a similar paradox.

Participation, involvement, engagement, buy-in, equality; these are all words that underlie organization transformation as we know it in the west.  These words are orthodoxy.  We believe in a democratized change management process.  We make daily decisions and take actions without questioning this belief.

I too am a believer.  I believe that participation increases the chances of success.  Maybe?

Maybe there’s a sequence here, and maybe the sequence goes back to the tireless discussion between management vs. leadership.  Maybe the foundation of transformation is hierarchical control, not egalitarian empowerment?

Let me explain.

Check out your NetFlix or i-Tunes and find the 1949 film Twelve O’clock High starring Gregory Peck.  It's a story about Peck taking over a B-17 squadron during the daytime bombing of Germany in WWII.  Peck is confronted with an undisciplined squadron with a low hit rate and high death rate.  He tries to lead the group but can’t.  He decides to enforce discipline to the extent that the men hate him so much that they all request transfers. 

Of course all turns out well.  The men get the message and Peck relinquishes leadership to the group – and it “saves the day.”  Hollywood drama?  Sure, but it makes a great point.  It reveals the transformation paradox: 


“you can’t lead if you're not in control!”

I relearned this lesson when I recently spent more than two years working in Korea.  The CEO of a $20 billion public company asked our team to build an Innovation capability within the organization to transform it from a market follower to a market leader.  A major issue holding the company back was the Korean culture of deference to hierarchy.  Everyone looked to the boss for ideas.  The deeper you got into the organization the deeper was the belief that “ideas are not my job.”

All of the innovation processes and tools used by our consulting team are based in the principle of participation.  You know the drill: everyone is equal; there are no bad ideas.  

The first six months of the project went well.  There was a lot of knowledge transfer.  Koreans love to learn.  Their Confucius based education system instills a belief in finite knowledge that can be learned and passed along.

Progress stalled as we got into the second six months.  This is where we brought teams together to use their newly acquired innovation skills.  This is where we developed insights from research; crashed insights to find ideas that had never been seen before; and assembled ideas into business opportunities.

Our teams fumbled.  We hit all of the walls: hierarchy within the teams slowed genuine idea generation; the reliance on rote learning inhibited pattern recognition; and even when we got good ideas the dynamic of deference slowed the exploration and synthesis of the ideas. 

Once the teams had reasonable change initiatives we coached them to develop plans to request funding for experiments to de-risk the ideas.  The plans were  to be based in vision, creativity, and energy.  We wanted the teams to sell ideas to their executives, not incremental business improvements.  They found this difficult.  The executive presentations were usually glorified spreadsheets – comfort zones for presenters and receivers of the information.

As we moved past the first year of work we realized that we had to change our approach.  Our biggest shift was to drop the principle of egalitarianism and take up the mantle of authority.  The Korean culture forced the paradox of transformation.

Now that I’ve left Korea I’ve discussed my experience with westerners who have practiced in other cultures like Russia, Saudi Arabia, China, and other countries in the east.  The message is consistent.  Our participative approach to change isn’t an immediate fit in countries with strong traditions of hierarchy and authority.  Empowerment has to be disciplined.  This sounds counter-intuitive, but that’s why it’s a paradox.

Is the west free of the transformation paradox?  I’m not convinced.  According to a recent survey reported in the Economist only 3% of organizations are “self-managed” through a set of core values.  In the remaining 97% there is a predominance of top-down, command and control management that stifles innovation, engagement, and performance.

Are we in the west living a delusion?  Is the principle of participation limiting transformation rather than driving it?  Is the transformation paradox one of the reasons that 70% of change initiatives fail?

These questions are worthy of debate if we are to get better at transforming organizations.  Maybe we’ll find answers to make adjustments, such as:
  1.  Using Authority:  People have been trained to look upward.  This is a powerful lever to start the process.  Employees need to have permission to participate.
  2. Codifying Creativity:  We can’t simply sit around and “ideate” changes.  We need to be specific on: how to generate ideas, recognize patterns, and synthesize information.
  3. Limiting Participation:  Can we really expect to kick start the process by getting “participation from everyone, everywhere?”  In the beginning only involve people who have the talent and passion to participate.
  4. Being Out Front:  The transformation leader has to lead from in front, not behind.  Don’t delegate in the beginning.  Be on stage.  Be visible.  Make the decisions.  Knowledge will transfer in due time.

It’s Twelve O'Clock High in the transformation business.

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Kim Jong-un. All for Un; Un for none

I'm leaving Seoul in a few days to go back home.  It's the first time in two years when I can say that I'm glad to leave.

I've been working with a client here; helping them use innovation to become more competitive.  I like the country and I love the people, but they have a crazy neighbor.

The Rocket's Red Glare
Since I've been here there has been a "North Korean incident" every few months.  The current escalations led the US Defense Secretary to say that this peninsula is only an inch away from serious violence at all times.

The most recent incident rings of the worst jingoism.  A few weeks ago the North had a failed launch of a missile.  It has received its fair share of criticism and ridicule from around the world - and specifically from South Korea.

In retaliation the North has railed that it will rain down special actions on the South that will "reduce the rat-like groups and the bases for provocations in three to four minutes."  I have no idea what this means, but it does sound ominous.

In an interview last week the US Secretary of State said that she hoped the new North Korean president, Kim Jong-un, would change paths in the North and build himself into a great leader for his people by bringing his country into a new era.  I hope she's right.

Through all this I marvel at my Korean friends.  They are impervious to the crazy threats and actions from the North.  They go about their lives with Confucius stoicism - or is that fatalism.