 |
| The Non-Participator |
“Cut out this guidance stuff and just tell me what to
do!” That’s a quote from my son when he
was nearing the end of his university education. Like most young people he was unclear and
anxious about his future. As a good
parent I was guiding him. It wasn’t
working; he wanted an answer. That’s the
paradox of parenting – it’s not your life, but you still have a responsibility. Leading organizational change has a similar paradox.
Participation, involvement, engagement, buy-in, equality;
these are all words that underlie organization transformation as we know it in
the west. These words are orthodoxy. We believe in a democratized change
management process. We make daily
decisions and take actions without questioning this belief.
I too am a believer.
I believe that participation increases the chances of success. Maybe?
Maybe there’s a sequence here, and maybe the sequence goes
back to the tireless discussion between management vs. leadership. Maybe the foundation of transformation is
hierarchical control, not egalitarian empowerment?
Let me explain.
Check out your NetFlix or i-Tunes and find the 1949 film Twelve O’clock High starring Gregory
Peck. It's a story about Peck taking
over a B-17 squadron during the daytime bombing of Germany in WWII. Peck is confronted with an undisciplined
squadron with a low hit rate and high death rate. He tries to lead the group but can’t. He decides to enforce discipline to the
extent that the men hate him so much that they all request transfers.
Of course all turns out well. The men get the message and Peck relinquishes
leadership to the group – and it “saves the day.” Hollywood drama? Sure, but it makes a great point. It reveals the transformation paradox:
“you can’t lead if
you're not in control!”
I relearned this lesson when I recently spent more than two
years working in Korea. The CEO of a $20
billion public company asked our team to build an Innovation capability within
the organization to transform it from a market follower to a market leader. A major issue holding the company back was the
Korean culture of deference to hierarchy.
Everyone looked to the boss for ideas.
The deeper you got into the organization the deeper was the belief that
“ideas are not my job.”
All of the innovation processes and tools used by our
consulting team are based in the principle of participation. You know the drill: everyone is equal; there
are no bad ideas.
The first six months
of the project went well. There was a
lot of knowledge transfer. Koreans love
to learn. Their Confucius based
education system instills a belief in finite knowledge that can be learned and
passed along.
Progress stalled as we got into the second six months. This is where we brought teams together to
use their newly acquired innovation skills.
This is where we developed insights from research; crashed insights to
find ideas that had never been seen before; and assembled ideas into business
opportunities.
Our teams fumbled. We
hit all of the walls: hierarchy within the teams slowed genuine idea
generation; the reliance on rote learning inhibited pattern recognition; and
even when we got good ideas the dynamic of deference slowed the exploration and synthesis of the ideas.
Once the teams had reasonable change initiatives we coached
them to develop plans to request funding for experiments to de-risk the
ideas. The plans were to be based in vision,
creativity, and energy. We wanted the
teams to sell ideas to their executives, not incremental business
improvements. They found this difficult. The executive presentations were usually
glorified spreadsheets – comfort zones for presenters and receivers of the
information.
As we moved past the first year of work we realized that we
had to change our approach. Our biggest
shift was to drop the principle of egalitarianism and take up the mantle of
authority. The Korean culture forced the
paradox of transformation.
Now that I’ve left Korea I’ve discussed my experience with
westerners who have practiced in other cultures like Russia, Saudi Arabia, China,
and other countries in the east. The
message is consistent. Our participative
approach to change isn’t an immediate fit in countries with strong traditions
of hierarchy and authority. Empowerment
has to be disciplined. This sounds
counter-intuitive, but that’s why it’s a paradox.
Is the west free of the transformation paradox? I’m not convinced. According to a recent survey reported in the Economist only 3% of organizations are
“self-managed” through a set of core values.
In the remaining 97% there is a predominance of top-down, command and
control management that stifles innovation, engagement, and performance.
Are we in the west living a delusion? Is the principle of participation limiting transformation
rather than driving it? Is the
transformation paradox one of the reasons that 70% of change initiatives fail?
These questions are worthy of debate if we are to get better
at transforming organizations. Maybe
we’ll find answers to make adjustments, such as:
- Using
Authority: People have been trained to look
upward. This is a powerful lever to
start the process. Employees need to
have permission to participate.
- Codifying
Creativity: We can’t simply sit around and
“ideate” changes. We need to be specific
on: how to generate ideas, recognize patterns, and synthesize information.
- Limiting
Participation: Can we really expect to kick start
the process by getting “participation from everyone, everywhere?” In the beginning only involve people who
have the talent and passion to participate.
- Being
Out Front: The transformation leader has to
lead from in front, not behind. Don’t
delegate in the beginning. Be on
stage. Be visible. Make the decisions. Knowledge will transfer in due time.